PIRAT: A Smarter Way to See Which Private Health Insurers Are Really Performing.

In the private health insurance market, it’s not always easy to separate strong, stable performers from those benefiting from a short-term bump. Data is plentiful, but it’s often scattered, inconsistent, and hard to interpret at a glance.

The Private Insurance Risk Assessment Tool—PIRAT, was built to change that.

It takes complex APRA data and distils it into a clear, balanced view of insurer performance. Instead of drowning in spreadsheets, you get a single scorecard that shows how each insurer is tracking across five areas that really matter:

• Premium revenue growth and stability 

• Financial discipline in managing expenses 

• Scale and retention of membership 

• Effectiveness in managing claims and benefits paid 

• Strength and solvency through assets-to-liabilities ratios

  
  

These scores run from 1 to 10, but they’re not just arbitrary numbers. Each one is anchored in per-policy performance and supported by three indicators: long-term growth (three-year CAGR), recent momentum (year-on-year change), and consistency over time (coefficient of variation). The result is a framework that rewards both performance and stability—spotlighting those who aren’t just doing well now, but have the resilience to keep doing well.

This matters because in private health insurance, volatility in any one area—claims, expenses, membership—can quickly ripple into profitability, member satisfaction, and long-term market position. A single year of revenue growth looks good in isolation, but if it’s paired with shrinking membership or erratic expense control, it’s a warning sign. PIRAT’s scoring keeps those factors in balance, so the picture you see is a true reflection of strength.

Once the high-level view points you toward the insurers worth watching, PIRAT lets you dig deeper. You can explore detailed data on revenue and profitability trends, membership changes, claims management efficiency, P&L breakdowns, and balance sheet shifts. The tool works equally well as a quick health check and as a deep-dive analysis platform.

Executive Summary Screen Shot P.I.R.A.T Dashboard

For analysts, executives, and decision-makers, that clarity can mean the difference between reacting to the market and anticipating it. It’s a way to benchmark the competition, spot weaknesses early, and support strategic decisions with confidence.

In a market where margins are thin and stakes are high, having a clear, consistent view of performance is a competitive advantage. PIRAT delivers that clarity.

If you’d like to see what PIRAT can reveal about your market position—or your competitors—book a discovery call with our team. We’ll walk you through the tool, show you how the scoring works, and explore the insights most relevant to your business.

Book a discovery call